Award-Winning Desserts from NYC's #1 Bakery
SHOP BIRTHDAY
SHOP NEW TREATS
SHOP BEST SELLERS
SHOP CAKES
SHOP TRUFFLES
SHOP COOKIES
SHOP BAKING MIX

JELL-O x Milk Bar

37,910

Our secret ingredient for a soft, flavor-packed cookie: JELL-O pudding. With pudding mixed right into the batter, our new JELL-O Banana Pudding and JELL-O Salted Butterscotch Pudding Cookies are fudgy, mouthwatering, and bursting with the iconic pudding flavors you love.

ORDER NOW
ORDER NOW

FALL TRUFFLE TIME

Get 10% off  Cider Donut Truffle Dozens and the Fall Truffle Party box for a limited time. 

Online only. Terms & conditions apply.

SHOP NOW
SHOP NOW

Fall in Love with Fall

Maple Cookie Butter Cake meets Cider Donut Truffles for a line up that feels like the season is finally starting. Fall's what you've been waiting for, so don't be shy.

ORDER NOW
ORDER NOW

Treats that Turn Heads

Shop the treats our community can’t stop talking about. We bake every batch fresh to order and ship them directly to your front door, so you can skip the grocery run and the messy kitchen and just focus on the sweet stuff.

ORDER NOW
ORDER NOW

Gifts for every occasion!

Whether you're celebrating a birthday or saying thank you to a colleague, you'll find goodies for life's little, big and everything-in-between moments.

Birthdays

Thank you

Congrats

Why choose Milk Bar?

ONE-OF-A-KIND TREATS

Try our award-winning classic Birthday Cake and our fan-favorite B’Day Cake Truffles!

Box Icon

THOUGHTFULLY PACKAGED

We make your treats fresh and flash-freeze ‘em for peak quality.

NATIONWIDE DELIVERY

If you’re a last-minute gifter, we’ve got you covered. Express shipping is available, with most orders eligible for delivery within 2 days

Shaking up the dessert scene since 2008.

SEND GROUP GIFTS

Got a list of folks to gift this year? We got you covered. We’re shipping our fan fave cakes, cookies, and pies coast to coast, all season long. Order yours now!

SHIP TO MULTIPLE ADDRESSES

ALL THE GOOD STUFF

We’re committed to making the world a more equitable and just place for all. Learn more about our charitable partners, social causes we’re committed to, and what we stand for.

Learn More

HEY, NICE TO TREAT YOU.

We’re Milk Bar. We’re a bakery making award-winning treats that ship nationwide. We’re here to help you send super awesome care packages for sharing, for giving, or for keeping all to yourself.