Greatest Hits

If we believed in popularity contests, these fan favorites and easy-to-order bundles would win. Here, you'll find goodies for life's little, big and everything-in-between moments.
Birthday Cake six inch front
Birthday Cake
From $50.00
Milk Bar Stamps - Final
Not Your Average Bakery
Learn More
Birthday Baller front
B'Day Baller
Milk Bar Stamps - Final

A combo of the classics, sized for small, but mighty group gatherings.

The Classic Front
The Classic

Tried and true b’day cake flavor fanatics, take note.

The Chocolately Classic Front

Calling all chocolate superfans.

Starter Kit front
Starter Kit
Sweet Spot front
Sweet Spot