BEST-SELLING TREATS

From impossible-to-put-down pie to iconic 3-layer cakes, our award-winning desserts are made for everyday celebrations. So whether you're sending a thank you gift, throwing an epic birthday bash, or just happy it's Wednesday — these treats are sure to please.

FREE STANDARD SHIPPING ON ORDERS $100+

Award-Winning Desserts from NYC's #1 Bakery
Featured
Featured
Newest
Ratings: High to low
Price: High to low
Price: Low to high
Front view of a 6
6" Birthday Cake
$65

You’ve never tried a birthday cake like this. Our bestselling Birthday Cake, inspired by the...

You’ve never tried a birthday cake like this. Our bestselling...
Milk Bar® Pie
Milk Bar® Pie
$53

Our signature, gooey Milk Bar Pie has a sticky, buttery,...
Strawberry & Corn Truffle Dozen
Strawberry & Corn Truffle Dozen
$40

Remember those long summer evenings and sweet backyard picnics? We’ve captured that sun-ripened magic by...

Remember those long summer evenings and sweet backyard picnics? We’ve...
The Milk Bar Sampler
The Milk Bar Sampler
$60

Have a little bit of everything! This sampler pack of classic Milk Bar treats gives...

Have a little bit of everything! This sampler pack of...
corn cookie overhead
Corn Cookie Tin - 6 Count
$28

The Corn Cookie is back, baby — but only for a limited time. Made with...

The Corn Cookie is back, baby — but only for...
The Cookie Faves Tin - 12 Count
The Cookie Faves Tin - 12 Count
$48

The Cookie Faves Tin is packed with 3 each of...
The Icons
Bundle & save $13
The Icons
$118 $105

Cake or pie? Yes. The Icons brings together our rainbow-flecked Birthday Cake and legendary Milk...

Cake or pie? Yes. The Icons brings together our rainbow-flecked...
Summer Assorted Truffle Box (18 Ct)
Summer Assorted Truffle Box (18 Ct)
$58

Sweeten up your next beach day, picnic, or summer BBQ with our truffle variety pack,...

Sweeten up your next beach day, picnic, or summer BBQ...
Assorted Cookie Tin - 6 Count
Assorted Cookie Tin - 6 Count
$28

Sometimes the correct answer is “one of each.” So we put together a cookie cornucopia...

Sometimes the correct answer is “one of each.” So we...

Baking Mix Variety Pack
Baking Mix Variety Pack
$39.99

Whether you’re craving a classic celebration or a rich chocolate fix, our variety pack delivers...

Whether you’re craving a classic celebration or a rich chocolate...
Chocolate Chip Cookie Truffle Dozen Box
Chocolate Chip Cookie Truffle Dozen Box
$40

The closest you can responsibly get to eating a ball of cookie dough. These bite-sized...

The closest you can responsibly get to eating a ball...
Sweets On-the-Go Duo
Sweets On-the-Go Duo
$66

Surprise your favorite host or sweet-tooth with the ultimate summer care package: our Sweets On-the-Go...

Surprise your favorite host or sweet-tooth with the ultimate summer...
6
6" Carrot Crackle Marshmallow Cake
$65

Back by popular demand, for a limited time only and better than ever. With layers...

Back by popular demand, for a limited time only and...
Lemon Bar Truffle Dozen
Lemon Bar Truffle Dozen
$40

Remember those sunny afternoons and the scent of mom's lemon bars cooling in the kitchen?...

Remember those sunny afternoons and the scent of mom's lemon...
SKIPPY® Peanut Butter Crunch Pie
SKIPPY® Peanut Butter Crunch Pie
$58

Our Chocolate PB Crunch Pie has a smooth chocolate shell...
6
6" Quadruple Chocolate Cake
$65

This chocolate on chocolate cake is not for the faint of heart.  We were so...

This chocolate on chocolate cake is not for the faint...
10
10" Carrot Crackle Marshmallow Cake
$140

Back by popular demand, for a limited time only and better than ever. With layers...

Back by popular demand, for a limited time only and...
A pile of birthday cake truffles sitting on top of a milk bar branded box.
B'Day Truffle Dozen Box
$40

We rolled all the childhood flavor of our signature cake...
Gluten Free Birthday Cake Front
6" Gluten-Free Birthday Cake
$78

Three tiers of rainbow-flecked, gluten-free vanilla B'Day cake layered with...
Birthday Truffle Sampler
Birthday Truffle Sampler
$58

18 decadent, bite-sized truffles. In this sampler gift box of our cult classic Cake Truffles,...

18 decadent, bite-sized truffles. In this sampler gift box of...
A 6
Bundle & save $8
The Birthday Classic
$105 $97

Tried and true b’day cake flavor fanatics, take note.
Birthday Truffle Gift Pack
Birthday Truffle Gift Pack
$43

We rolled all the childhood flavor of our signature cake into these rainbow-flecked, vanilla-happy bites...

We rolled all the childhood flavor of our signature cake...
The Big B’Day Gift
Bundle & save $13
The Big B’Day Gift
$108 $95

A birthday-flavored no-brainer that brings together all the heavy hitters for an all-out celebration. This...

A birthday-flavored no-brainer that brings together all the heavy hitters...
The Little Somethings
Bundle & save $6
The Little Somethings
$108 $102

Sometimes you just want a little something sweet. With this party pack, we’re giving you...

Sometimes you just want a little something sweet. With this...
The Double Truffle
Bundle & save $6
The Double Truffle
$80 $74

We doubled down on our truffle game for this megapack of bite-sized beauties. One dozen...

We doubled down on our truffle game for this megapack...
The Cheerleader
Bundle & save $4
The Cheerleader
$109 $105

Everyone needs a little encouragement sometimes, and we’ve found that dessert does a pretty amazing...

Everyone needs a little encouragement sometimes, and we’ve found that...
6
Bundle & save $12
The Newbie
$158 $146

This can’t-fail starter pack is ideal for initiating Milk Bar rookies into the wide world...

This can’t-fail starter pack is ideal for initiating Milk Bar...
Cookie Classics Assorted Tin - 6 Count
Cookie Classics Assorted Tin - 6 Count
$28

From the bakery that brought you your fave original Cookie creations, comes a take on...

From the bakery that brought you your fave original Cookie...
Compost Cookie® Tin - 6 Count
Compost Cookie® Tin - 6 Count
$28

The original sweet and salty kitchen sink cookie, with chocolate chips in a deep vanilla...

The original sweet and salty kitchen sink cookie, with chocolate...
overhead close up view of the cornflake chocolate chip marshmallow cookie.
Cornflake Chocolate Chip Marshmallow Cookie Tin - 6 Count
$28

Our crunchy, chewy riff on the classic chocolate chip cookie, packed full of caramelized cornflakes...

Our crunchy, chewy riff on the classic chocolate chip cookie,...
The Sweet Spot
Bundle & save $10
The Sweet Spot
$121 $111

Not too big, but definitely not too small — you’ll always hit The Sweet Spot...

Not too big, but definitely not too small — you’ll...
Chocolate Chip 'N Chunk Cookie Tin - 6 Count
Chocolate Chip 'N Chunk Cookie Tin - 6 Count
$28

Because there are few things in life better than a soft chocolate chip cookie, we...

Because there are few things in life better than a...
overhead of the confetti cookie
Confetti Cookie Tin - 6 Count
$28

All those familiar box-mix Birthday Cake flavors — dreamy vanilla, rich butter, rainbow sprinkles —...

All those familiar box-mix Birthday Cake flavors — dreamy vanilla,...
Oatmeal Cream Cookie Tin - 6 Count
Oatmeal Cream Cookie Tin - 6 Count
$28

Based on the lunch box favorite, the Oatmeal Cream Cookie channels nostalgia with its soft...

Based on the lunch box favorite, the Oatmeal Cream Cookie...
The Ultimate Birthday
Bundle & save $13
The Ultimate Birthday
$186 $173

We at Milk Bar take birthdays very seriously (in that we believe in unapologetically large...

We at Milk Bar take birthdays very seriously (in that...
Triple PB Cookie Tin - 6 Count
Triple PB Cookie Tin - 6 Count
$28

The Triple PB Cookie takes the soft and nutty energy of a peanut butter cookie...

The Triple PB Cookie takes the soft and nutty energy...
10
10" Birthday Cake
$140

You’ve never tried a birthday cake like this. Our bestselling Birthday Cake, inspired by the...

You’ve never tried a birthday cake like this. Our bestselling...
Assorted Cookie Tin - 12 Count
Assorted Cookie Tin - 12 Count
$48

What’s better than one of each cookie? Two of each. This 12-count cookie tin has...

What’s better than one of each cookie? Two of each....
Cookie Classics Assorted Tin - 12 Count
Cookie Classics Assorted Tin - 12 Count
$48

From the bakery that brought you your fave original cookie creations, comes a take on...

From the bakery that brought you your fave original cookie...
Oatmeal Cream Cookie Tin - 12 Count
Oatmeal Cream Cookie Tin - 12 Count
$48

Based on the lunch box favorite, the Oatmeal Cream Cookie channels nostalgia with its soft...

Based on the lunch box favorite, the Oatmeal Cream Cookie...
Chocolate Chip 'N Chunk Cookie Tin - 12 Count
Chocolate Chip 'N Chunk Cookie Tin - 12 Count
$48

Because there are few things in life better than a soft chocolate chip cookie, we...

Because there are few things in life better than a...
Triple PB Cookie Tin - 12 Count
Triple PB Cookie Tin - 12 Count
$48

The Triple PB Cookie takes the soft and nutty energy of a peanut butter cookie...

The Triple PB Cookie takes the soft and nutty energy...
Compost Cookie® Tin - 12 Count
Compost Cookie® Tin - 12 Count
$48

The original sweet and salty kitchen sink cookie, with chocolate chips in a deep vanilla...

The original sweet and salty kitchen sink cookie, with chocolate...
overhead close up view of the cornflake chocolate chip marshmallow cookie.
Cornflake Chocolate Chip Marshmallow Cookie Tin - 12 Count
$48

Our crunchy, chewy riff on the classic chocolate chip cookie, packed full of caramelized cornflakes...

Our crunchy, chewy riff on the classic chocolate chip cookie,...
overhead of the confetti cookie
Confetti Cookie Tin - 12 Count
$48

All those familiar box-mix Birthday Cake flavors — dreamy vanilla, rich butter, rainbow sprinkles —...

All those familiar box-mix Birthday Cake flavors — dreamy vanilla,...