Ice Cream Shop

The

Pints you won’t want to put back in the freezer. Order today, enjoy tomorrow. They’re great as gifts, too.

Featured
Featured
Newest
Ratings: High to low
Price: High to low
Price: Low to high
The Ice Cream Sampler
$60.00
The Ice Cream Sampler

For when you want it all. This 5-pack of scoopable, custard-style ice cream is here...

For when you want it all. This 5-pack of scoopable,...

Quick View
5 Chocolate Mint Cookies N' Cream Ice Cream pints stacked.
$60.00
Chocolate Mint Cookies N' Cream Ice Cream

This tasty pint is the perfect mix of chocolate mint ice cream, chocolate cookie batter,...

This tasty pint is the perfect mix of chocolate mint...

Quick View
5 Chocolate Birthday Ice Cream pints stacked.
$60.00
Chocolate Birthday Ice Cream

We took our famous Birthday flavor and seriously upped the ante. This ultra-creamy pint has...

We took our famous Birthday flavor and seriously upped the...

Quick View
Cereal Milk Ice Cream and Birthday Cake Ice Cream Pints beside a 6
$82.00
Strawberries N’ Cream

Whether you’re celebrating an anniversary, a summer birthday, or the fact that you love dessert,...

Whether you’re celebrating an anniversary, a summer birthday, or the...

Quick View
5 Ice cream pints sitting on top of the Milk Bar Sampler tin.
$110.00
The Party Spread

Go big or go home—that’s our motto. This spread is packed with Assorted Cookies and...

Go big or go home—that’s our motto. This spread is...

Quick View
2 PB Chocolate Cookie Crush Ice Cream Pints, a pile of Chocolate B'day Cake Truffles, and a stack of Chocolate Confetti Cookies next to a cookie tin.
$77.00
The Chocolate Lover’s Dream

This trio of chocolate goodies is unapologetically indulgent and delicious. Send it to the chocolate...

This trio of chocolate goodies is unapologetically indulgent and delicious....

Quick View
5 Birthday Cake Pints Stacked
$60.00
Birthday Cake Ice Cream

Our award-winning Birthday Cake, packed into a hot pink pint with B’Day cake-flavored ice cream,...

Our award-winning Birthday Cake, packed into a hot pink pint...

Quick View
Assorted Truffle box with 2 Cereal Milk Ice Cream Pints
$73.00
Sundae in the Park

We’re not saying you have to turn this duo of Cereal Milk Ice Cream and...

We’re not saying you have to turn this duo of...

Quick View
5 Cereal Milk Pints Stacked
$60.00
Cereal Milk Ice Cream

Ultra-creamy, custard-style Cereal Milk Ice Cream (sweet and salty, a little corny, tastes like the...

Ultra-creamy, custard-style Cereal Milk Ice Cream (sweet and salty, a...

Quick View
6
$104.00
The Birthday Scoop

The flavors that put us on the map in ultra-creamy ice cream form, *plus* an...

The flavors that put us on the map in ultra-creamy...

Quick View
5 Cornflake Chocolate Chip Marshmallow Pints stacked
$60.00
Cornflake Chocolate Chip Marshmallow Ice Cream

Our riff on your classic chocolate chip cookie dough ice cream remixed Milk Bar style:...

Our riff on your classic chocolate chip cookie dough ice...

Quick View
Full shot of ice cream pints and unwrapped cookies sitting on a dozen cookie tin
$90.00
DIY Ice Cream Sammie Party

Oh yes we did. A take-home kit with ice cream sammie-making essentials, including a dozen...

Oh yes we did. A take-home kit with ice cream...

Quick View
5 PB Chocolate Cookie Crush pints stacked
$60.00
Peanut Butter Chocolate Cookie Crush Ice Cream

Meet your new crush: peanut butter chocolate ice cream with peanut butter cookie crumbs and...

Meet your new crush: peanut butter chocolate ice cream with...

Quick View
whole unwrapped pie next to 4 stacked ice cream pints
$95.00
The Pie Lovers Pack

If you can't keep your paws off the Milk Bar classics (hint: pie)—this one's for...

If you can't keep your paws off the Milk Bar...

Quick View
5 Pints of Pie Ice Cream stacked
$60.00
Pie Ice Cream

We swirled our signature gooey, buttery Milk Bar Pie filling and crushed toasted oat crust...

We swirled our signature gooey, buttery Milk Bar Pie filling...

Quick View

So, what's it taste like?

Cereal Milk
Cereal Milk started as a stroke of pure inspiration at the corner store. Then it became a panna cotta. Then it became soft serve. Ultra-creamy, custard-style Cereal Milk Ice Cream (sweet and salty, a little corny, tastes like the bottom of your cereal bowl) with our signature cornflake crunch swirled in.
Birthday Cake
You *know* we had to bring Birthday to your freezer, too. Get all the childhood flavor of our award-winning Birthday Cake, packed into a hot pink pint with B'Day cake flavored ice cream, B'Day crumbs, and ribbons of B'Day frosting. Candles optional.
Cornflake chocolate chip marshmallow
Our riff on your classic chocolate chip cookie dough ice cream remixed Milk Bar style: cookie dough flavored ice cream with cornflake crunch, chocolate-flavored chunks, and gooey, melted marshmallow swirls.
Pie
We swirled our signature gooey, buttery Milk Bar Pie filling and crushed toasted oat crust into an ultra-creamy, custard-style deep vanilla ice cream base. Want to really up the ante? Serve a slice of the original Milk Bar Pie à la mode with a scoop.
Peanut Butter Chocolate Cookie Crush
Meet your new crush: peanut butter chocolate ice cream with peanut butter cookie crumbs and fudgy chocolate cookie batter. *Swoon*.

Pints that ship? Yep! Here's how it works.

Box Icon

Got questions about your ice cream delivery?

We got answers.

How will my ice cream arrive?

We ship our ice cream next day so that it arrives in perfect condition on your doorstep. We secure your pints in a specially designed, insulated box, cold-packed with dry ice so that your ice cream stays cool in transit.

Not home when it arrives? Your ice cream's safe in the box for up to 24 hours.

If you are purchasing other treats along with ice cream, your ice cream will be shipped in a separate box.

Got additional questions about ice cream? Please reach out to help@milkbarstore.com! We are happy to help :)

How do I handle and dispose of dry ice?

For your safety, do not handle dry ice with bare hands. Keep dry ice in a well-ventilated area until it transforms from solid to gas. Allow dry ice to dissipate before disposal.

How long will my ice cream stay fresh?

Please enjoy your ice cream by the best by date printed on the bottom of your pint.