FREE SHIPPING ON ORDERS $100+ Shop Now
SCHEDULE ORDER UP TO 30 DAYS IN ADVANCE
WE SHIP NATIONWIDE! SEND TREATS
INGREDIENTS: BUTTER (CREAM, NATURAL FLAVORS), SUGAR, BROWN SUGAR, HEAVY CREAM, EGG YOLKS, 100% WHOLE GRAIN OATS, WHEAT FLOUR (MALTED BARLEY FLOUR, NIACIN, IRON, THIAMIN MONONITRATE, RIBOFLAVIN, FOLIC ACID), EGGS, DEGERMED YELLOW CORN FLOUR, INSTANT NONFAT DRY MILK (NONFAT MILK, VITAMINS A & D ADDED), CONFECTIONER’S SUGAR (SUGAR, CORN STARCH), SALT, NATURAL FLAVOR, BAKING POWDER (SODIUM PYROPHOSPHATE, SODIUM BICARBONATE, CORNSTARCH, MONOCALCIUM PHOSPHATE), BAKING SODA
Made in a facility that processes PEANUTS AND TREE NUTS
Contains: milk, eggs, wheat
How we make Milk Bar Pie
Making Milk Bar Pie is a transformation of simple ingredients into extraordinary flavors! It starts with a hearty oat cookie base, crumbled and shaped into a crust, followed by a can’t-stop-eating-it custard made with egg yolks, milk, sugar, and LOTS of butter. Bake until just set and jiggly in the center and then cool out of the oven and serve cold! For the full recipe, click here — or just order pie for delivery!
When you send a pie as a gift to someone, you’re not just sending pie — you’re sending a good time! Our signature ooey-gooey pie makes the perfect gift for any occasion (even if that’s no occasion at all). Our nationwide pie delivery service makes sure your gift arrives in perfect condition and ready to devour. All you have to do is wait for an enthusiastic thank you call..
You might be wondering, “where can I get pie?” We’ve got good news: Getting Milk Bar Pie delivered to your home couldn’t be easier. Simply order pie online for delivery at milkbarstore.com and we’ll ship a whole pie right to you — or, if you live near a Milk Bar, we’ll deliver a whole pie or slice of pie to you via our delivery partners.
Some people wonder how getting a freshly made cake from commissary to doorstep overnight is even possible. But we’d never send you anything we weren’t proud of. Everything you order from our site is fresh-baked, flash-frozen, cold-packed, and insulated for its journey to you in a beautiful branded box so that it arrives safe and perfect. Sending a gift? Add a personalized message to your package so your loved one feels extra special.
First, we perfected our shipping method so that everything arrives in great shape. Then, we started shipping nationwide. Now, we’ve extended our delivery window throughout the week (except Sundays — everyone needs a day off!) anywhere in the US of A. And if you order your Milk Bar care package by noon EST, we’ll make sure that it arrives the very next day.
Birthdays. Holidays. Milestones. We know you know how to celebrate life’s big moments, but what if we told you that you can celebrate… anytime? At Milk Bar, we’re firm believers in celebrating every single day with something sweet. Dessert is about love and joy — how we show it, how we share it, how we give it to ourselves. Everyone deserves a cookie from time to time. Why not now?
