Halloween Mystery Offer

At checkout, use code TRICK or code TREAT to unlock a mystery Halloween offer — but you won’t know what you got ‘til you try. Offer ends 10/28. Terms & Conditions Apply.

Featured
Featured
Newest
Ratings: High to low
Price: High to low
Price: Low to high
Front view of a 6
6" Birthday Cake
$65

You’ve never tried a birthday cake like this. Our bestselling Birthday Cake, inspired by the...

You’ve never tried a birthday cake like this. Our bestselling...
Milk Bar® Pie
Milk Bar® Pie
$53

Our signature, gooey Milk Bar Pie has a sticky, buttery,...
The Milk Bar Sampler
The Milk Bar Sampler
$60

Have a little bit of everything! This sampler pack of classic Milk Bar treats gives...

Have a little bit of everything! This sampler pack of...
Chocolate Chip Cookie Truffle Dozen Box
Chocolate Chip Cookie Truffle Dozen Box
$40

The closest you can responsibly get to eating a ball of cookie dough. These bite-sized...

The closest you can responsibly get to eating a ball...
SKIPPY® Peanut Butter Crunch Pie
SKIPPY® Peanut Butter Crunch Pie
$58

Our Chocolate PB Crunch Pie has a smooth chocolate shell...
Assorted Cookie Tin - 6 Count
Assorted Cookie Tin - 6 Count
$28

Sometimes the correct answer is “one of each.” So we put together a cookie cornucopia...

Sometimes the correct answer is “one of each.” So we...
6
6" Quadruple Chocolate Cake
$65

This chocolate on chocolate cake is not for the faint of heart.  We were so...

This chocolate on chocolate cake is not for the faint...
The Cookie Faves Tin - 12 Count
The Cookie Faves Tin - 12 Count
$48

The Cookie Faves Tin is packed with 3 each of...
Birthday Truffle Gift Pack
Birthday Truffle Gift Pack
$43

We rolled all the childhood flavor of our signature cake into these rainbow-flecked, vanilla-happy bites...

We rolled all the childhood flavor of our signature cake...

Gluten Free Birthday Cake Front
6" Gluten-Free Birthday Cake
$78

Three tiers of rainbow-flecked, gluten-free vanilla B'Day cake layered with...
Cookie Classics Assorted Tin - 6 Count
Cookie Classics Assorted Tin - 6 Count
$28

From the bakery that brought you your fave original Cookie creations, comes a take on...

From the bakery that brought you your fave original Cookie...
A pile of birthday cake truffles sitting on top of a milk bar branded box.
B'Day Truffle Dozen Box
$40

We rolled all the childhood flavor of our signature cake...
Quadruple Chocolate Cake Duo
Bundle & save $8
Quadruple Chocolate Cake Duo
$97

Call it, 5 times the chocolate, with this super indulgent combo of our new, over...

Call it, 5 times the chocolate, with this super indulgent...
The Big B’Day Gift
Bundle & save $13
The Big B’Day Gift
$95

A birthday-flavored no-brainer that brings together all the heavy hitters for an all-out celebration. This...

A birthday-flavored no-brainer that brings together all the heavy hitters...
Triple PB Cookie Tin - 6 Count
Triple PB Cookie Tin - 6 Count
$28

The Triple PB Cookie takes the soft and nutty energy of a peanut butter cookie...

The Triple PB Cookie takes the soft and nutty energy...
Oatmeal Cream Cookie Tin - 6 Count
Oatmeal Cream Cookie Tin - 6 Count
$28

Based on the lunch box favorite, the Oatmeal Cream Cookie channels nostalgia with its soft...

Based on the lunch box favorite, the Oatmeal Cream Cookie...
Chocolate Chip 'N Chunk Cookie Tin - 6 Count
Chocolate Chip 'N Chunk Cookie Tin - 6 Count
$28

Because there are few things in life better than a soft chocolate chip cookie, we...

Because there are few things in life better than a...
A 6
Bundle & save $8
The Birthday Classic
$97

Tried and true b’day cake flavor fanatics, take note.
10
10" Birthday Cake
$140

You’ve never tried a birthday cake like this. Our bestselling Birthday Cake, inspired by the...

You’ve never tried a birthday cake like this. Our bestselling...
Assorted Cookie Tin - 12 Count
Assorted Cookie Tin - 12 Count
$48

What’s better than one of each cookie? Two of each. This 12-count cookie tin has...

What’s better than one of each cookie? Two of each....
Cookie Classics Assorted Tin - 12 Count
Cookie Classics Assorted Tin - 12 Count
$48

From the bakery that brought you your fave original cookie creations, comes a take on...

From the bakery that brought you your fave original cookie...

Oatmeal Cream Cookie Tin - 12 Count
Oatmeal Cream Cookie Tin - 12 Count
$48

Based on the lunch box favorite, the Oatmeal Cream Cookie channels nostalgia with its soft...

Based on the lunch box favorite, the Oatmeal Cream Cookie...
Chocolate Chip 'N Chunk Cookie Tin - 12 Count
Chocolate Chip 'N Chunk Cookie Tin - 12 Count
$48

Because there are few things in life better than a soft chocolate chip cookie, we...

Because there are few things in life better than a...
Triple PB Cookie Tin - 12 Count
Triple PB Cookie Tin - 12 Count
$48

The Triple PB Cookie takes the soft and nutty energy of a peanut butter cookie...

The Triple PB Cookie takes the soft and nutty energy...