Whole Milk Bar Pie Overhead
Milk Bar Pie Slices Stacked
Milk Bar Pie slices overhead
side view of Milk Bar Pie slices stacked
Featured AB
Whole Milk Bar Pie Overhead
Milk Bar Pie Slices Stacked
Milk Bar Pie slices overhead
side view of Milk Bar Pie slices stacked
Featured AB

Milk Bar® Pie

Our signature, gooey Milk Bar Pie has a sticky, buttery, salty-sweet filling in a hearty oat-cookie crust. *This* is the pie that put Milk Bar on the map. Get it delivered fresh, anywhere in the USA. We dare you not to have a second slice.

10” pie serves 8-10.

Flavor Highlights: Salty-Sweet | Buttery | Hearty Oat-Cookie Crust

Get +53 points on this purchase to use towards *free* treats when you join The First Bite Club! Information Icon

Monthly Care Package

Whether you’re a super gifter, creature of habit or just love the thrill of getting something sweet delivered every month, we’ve got your back. This monthly delivery option allows you to sit back and relax, knowing that we’ll send (your favorite) Milk Bar treats, every month. Your order will arrive the same time each month, so you can plan your dessert breaks accordingly. If you want to cancel or adjust the details of your subscription, just log into your Milk Bar account and navigate to "manage subscriptions" to make changes, or give us a shout at: help@milkbarstore.com,

Please note, monthly care package orders are not eligible for delivery date selection and typically ship within 1-3 days of purchase. If you have a one-time purchase in the cart with the monthly care package, you cannot select a delivery date. In order to select a delivery date, place one-time purchases separately from the monthly care package.

Possible uses for monthly delivery:

  • Always having something sweet on hand when company calls
  • Stocking your office break room with goodies so everyone likes you
  • Monthly “I see you” moments on the doorstep of someone you like/love
  • Making sure your midnight snack supplies are maintained
  • An autopilot option for nonstop birthday gifting needs
  • Your college kid needs to know cookies don’t grow on trees but do show up every 4 weeks give or take
  • Your bookclub loves a good snack
  • The thrill of seeing the white and pink box on your doorstep

Add Blueberry Muffin Cake Truffle Dozen Box to save $8

This item bundled with Blueberry Muffin Cake Truffle Dozen Box completes a set.

save $8 save $8 save $8
Add to Cart - $53.00
Box Icon
We ship nationwide directly to your door.
Schedule your order up to 30 days in advance.
Write a personalized gift note

More Treats

Whether it’s a party of one or a party of ten, we’ve got you with epic desserts.

Assorted Cookie Tin

Add -- $27
Added

Birthday Truffles 3-Pack

Add -- $8
Added

Chocolate Birthday Truffles 3-Pack

Add -- $8
Added

Don't take our word for it

Write a Review

Write a Review

Score

How would you rate the quality of the Milk Bar product?

How would you rate the delivery or in-store pick up experience?

Would you order from Milk Bar online again?

What was the occasion for Milk Bar?

How did you hear about Milk Bar?

How likely are you to recommend Milk Bar to your family or friends?

Thank you for posting a review!

Your review was sent successfully and is now waiting for our staff to publish it.

Load More
HOW TO GET TREATS DELIVERED

How to Get Treats Delivered

CHOOSE YOUR CARE PACKAGE

Pick your treats and add them to your cart. Plus, write a personalized gift note!

SCHEDULE YOUR DELIVERY

Select your delivery date during checkout. You can schedule your order up to 30 days in advance.

Box Icon

CHECK YOUR DOORSTEP

We ship treats seven days a week, anywhere in the USA. Your treats will arrive with cold packs and protective wrap, so they’re fresh and ready to be devoured.

Wheat
Eggs
Milk

Our treats are made in a facility that processes:

Peanuts & Tree Nuts

Ingredients:

butter (cream, Natural flavors), Sugar, Brown sugar, Heavy cream, Egg yolks, 100% whole grain oats, Wheat flour (malted barley flour, Niacin, Iron, Thiamin mononitrate, Riboflavin, Folic acid), Eggs, Degermed yellow corn flour, Instant nonfat dry milk (nonfat milk, Vitamins a & d added), Confectioner’s sugar (sugar, Corn starch), Salt, Natural flavor, Baking powder (sodium pyrophosphate, Sodium bicarbonate, Cornstarch, Monocalcium phosphate), Baking soda

how we make milk bar pie
making milk bar pie is a transformation of simple ingredients into extraordinary flavors! it starts with a hearty oat cookie base, Crumbled and shaped into a crust, Followed by a can’t-stop-eating-it custard made with egg yolks, Milk, Sugar, And lots of butter. bake until just set and jiggly in the center and then cool out of the oven and serve cold! for the full recipe, click here — or just order pie for delivery!
Enjoy free standard shipping ($15 value) on all orders over $100+ at milkbarstore.com when shipping to the continental United States. Offer excludes taxes, gift cards, and donations. Offer valid on orders placed online in the United States only from 5/1/23 at 10:00AM EST through 5/11/23 at 11:59PM EST.

Storage Instructions

Pies require refrigeration and stay fresh in the refrigerator for seven days and up to one month in the freezer.

Serving Instructions

Pies require refrigeration but can be enjoyed at any temperature–you pick! The 10” pie serves 8-10.