2017 Holiday FAQ
Sunday 12/24: Close early at 6pm*. Midtown Milk Bar stays open until 10:30pm
Monday 12/25: Closed.
Tuesday 12/26: Closed except midtown milk bar.
Sunday 12/31: Close early at 9pm*
Monday 1/1: Open late at 11am*
Sunday 12/24: Close early at 4pm.
Monday 12/25: Closed.
Monday 1/1: Open at 11am.
Monday 12/25: 4pm – 11pm
Open normal hours
Holiday Gifts Made Easy
Order ahead to pick up in store, or have goodies shipped right to your door!
Can I order ahead? When should I place my order?
Order ahead to pick up in store
The last day to place a reservation order for
Thanksgiving… Sunday Nov 19 for pick up on Wednesday Nov 22 by 6pm
Christmas… Thursday Dec 21 for pick up on Sunday Dec 24 by 6pm
New Years… Thursday Dec 28 for pick up on Sunday Dec 31 by 8pm
We accept shipping orders up to 1 month in advance.
We recommend selecting an arrival date 1-2 days early for all time sensitive events, all of our products are freezer friendly and can be stored frozen for up to 1 month.
The last day to place a shipping order to arrive in time for
Thanksgiving… Tuesday Nov 21 at 12pm, with NEXT DAY AIR shipping speed selected.
Christmas… Thursday Dec 21 at 12pm, with NEXT DAY AIR shipping speed selected.
New Years… Thursday Dec 21 at 12pm, with NEXT DAY AIR shipping speed selected.
Large corporate and bulk orders
If you are working with our corporate orders team to put together a large holiday gift order or to cater an event, we suggest the following cut off dates in order to avoid rush charges.
Finalize your order by monday november 13th.
Hanukkah,Christmas + New Years
Finalize your order by monday december 12th.
Are you serving anything special for the holidays?
In addition to everyone’s favorite Thanksgiving Croissant, we have two spectacular seasonal cake and truffle flavors available for a limited time!
Available in November Only
Pumpkin Pie Cake: spiced pumpkin cake layered with graham cracker cheesecake, rich pumpkin ganache and candied pumpkin seeds!
Pumpkin Pie Truffles: our spiced pumpkin cake, blended with more pumpkin, rolled in white chocolate and coated in spiced pie & graham cracker crumbs.
Available in December Only
Peppermint Cornflake Marshmallow Chocolate Chip Cookies: a twist on a chocolate chip cookie with candy canes for holiday cheer, this cookie is made with cornflakes, mini chocolate chips, mini marshmallows and crushed up candy canes! crunchy, chewy and minty!
Grasshopper Cake: alternating chocolate chip cake and chocolate malt cake, layered with mint cheesecake, rich chocolate crumbs and finished with a cookies & cream frosting! on the menu through december, it’s the perfect holiday match for those frosty winter days!
Grasshopper Truffles: chocolate chip cake mixed with mint cheesecake, coated in white chocolate and rolled in chocolate crumbs!
What is the shelf life of milk bar products, will they stay fresh if i place my order early?
Cookies can be stored at room temperature for 5 days, or can be frozen to keep fresh for up to a month.
All other products should be stored in the fridge for 5 days, or frozen to keep fresh for up to a month.
Do you offer gift packaging or customization?
While we do not offer gift wrapping, most of our items come packaged in gift ready boxes and tins!
For a large orders (20 units or more) customized stickers and gift notes are available through our corporate orders team. see here for more info!