WEDDINGS & CELEBRATIONS CAKES
Our cakes are uniquely Milk Bar in style – we never frost our iconic naked cakes, because we always want to highlight all the beautiful, decadent layers!
Whether it’s the biggest day of your life, a milestone birthday, a graduation or just because – Milk Bar’s selection of cakes and desserts will help turn your special event into an extraordinary occasion. From traditional tiered cakes, to playful dessert tables, we have just what you need to wow your guests.
Milk Bar would be honored to supply the sweetness for your celebration!
Along with the information provided below, you may also want to take a look at the answers to some of our commonly asked questions in our Wedding & Celebration Cakes FAQ. Still have questions or ready to place an order?
TIERED CAKE OPTIONS
Tiered cake options start at $12 per slice
Three Tier: serves up to 60
Four Tier Cake: serves up to 125
Six Tier Cake: serves up to 210 (NYC/DC ONLY)
We also offer untiered cakes for supplemental servings, which start at $49
Supplemental Untiered Cake serves up to 12
Supplement Untiered Cake serves up to 30
Supplemental Untiered Cake serves up to 60
Supplemental Sheet Cake serves up to 150
Cost does not include delivery fee, and applicable tax.
Tiers can be mixed and matched from any of the flavors currently available at our bakery!
When ordering a wedding cake, additional 10″, 14″, and 18″x26″ sheet cakes can be added to your order for cutting. We also offer cookies, cake truffles and slices of crack pie® as takeaways, in addition to alternative desserts like the cake truffle croquembouche!
image credits
1. Sasithon Pooviriyaku
2. Sarah Tew
3. Wild Scout Photo Co
4. Ryon Lockhart
5. Rebecca Yale
6. Redfield Photography
CAKE TASTINGS
Wedding cake tasting packages can be purchased online for pick-up at any of our nyc stores with 3 or more days notice, or they can be shipped directly to any u.s. address! To schedule a wedding tasting at our new Milk Bar Flagship at Logan Circle, email dcevents@milkbarstore.com.
Our wedding cake tasting package includes samples of each of the 8 cake flavors currently available on our menu, cut into 1″x1″ two bite samples for you to enjoy. If you will be sampling with your wedding party we recommend ordering 1 box for every 2 people in the group. Once you have had your tasting, just reach out to our team and we’d be happy to assist you in selecting the final flavor profile of your cake!
ORDERING TIME LINE:
We require a minimum of 1 month notice, and will accept orders up to 6 months in advance. During our busy season (May-October) we ask for 3-6 months notice to ensure we can fit you onto our production and delivery schedule.
DELIVERY IN NYC & DC
We can deliver to venues in NYC or DC 7 days a week between 9am and 6pm. We ask for a 3 hour delivery window for our drivers. We can also have your cake ready for pick up at any time from these Milk Bar kitchens:
382 Metropolitan Ave, Brooklyn NY
1090 I St NW, Washington, DC 20001
DELIVERY OUTSIDE OF NYC
We ship our wedding cakes nationwide via Fedex Priority Air. Cakes are shipped in an insulated foam shipping box designed for perishable goods and packaged with ice packs and protective foil filling.
CAKE FLAVORS
10″ Chocolate Chip Cake
$113.30
Chocolate chip cake, passion fruit curd, chocolate crumbs, coffee frosting.
6″ Chocolate Chip Cake
$50.50
Chocolate chip cake, passion fruit curd, chocolate crumbs, coffee frosting.
10″ Salted Pretzel Cake
$113.30
Salted pretzel cake, chocolate stout ganache, pretzel crumbs, burnt honey frosting.
6″ Salted Pretzel Cake
$50.50
Salted pretzel cake, chocolate stout ganache, pretzel crumbs, burnt honey frosting.
10″ Strawberry Lemon Cake
$113.30
Vanilla cake, lemon cheesecake, milk crumbs, pickled tristar strawberry jam, pickled strawberry frosting.
6″ Strawberry Lemon Cake
$50.50
Vanilla cake, lemon cheesecake, milk crumbs, pickled tristar strawberry jam, pickled strawberry frosting.
MORE FROM MILK BAR!
6″ Birthday Cake
$50.50
Vanilla rainbow cake, rainbow cake crumbs, sprinkles, vanilla frosting.
B’day Truffle Dozen Box
$25.00
Vanilla rainbow cake, vanilla infused milk, white chocolate, rainbow cake crumbs.
Crack Pie®
$48
Toasted oat crust, gooey butter filling.
XL Cookie Tin
$62.00
Gift tin of 2 dozen assorted cookies.