WEDDING & CELEBRATIONS CAKES

With unfrosted sides highlighting all of the delicious fillings layered inside, our iconic “naked” cakes will make any event extraordinary. We offer cakes in a variety of sizes, from classic layered cake rounds to six-tiered stunners.

Tiered wedding cakes are available for servings between 45 and 210, with prices starting at $12 per slice. We also offer un-tiered cakes for supplemental servings with prices starting at $49 a cake. Our team is here to work with you to create the best arrangement for your event needs.

TIERED CAKE OPTIONS

Tiered cake options start at $12 per slice and can serve 45-210 guests per cake. Tiers can be mixed and matched from any of the flavors currently available at our bakery!

We also offer untiered cakes for supplemental servings, which start at $49. Additional 10″, 14″, and 18″x 26″ sheet cakes can be added to your order with as little as 2 weeks notice. We also offer cookies, cake truffles and slices of crack pie® as takeaways, in addition to alternative desserts like the cake truffle croquembouche!

Cost does not include shipping fee and applicable tax.

CAKE TASTINGS

Wedding cake tasting packages can be purchased online for pick-up at any of our stores with 3 or more days notice, or they can be shipped directly to any u.s. address!

Our wedding cake tasting package includes samples of each of the 8 cake flavors currently available on our menu, cut into 1″x1″ two bite samples for you to enjoy. If you will be sampling with your wedding party we recommend ordering 1 box for every 2 people in the group. Once you have had your tasting, just reach out to our team and we’d be happy to assist you in selecting the final flavor profile of your cake!

ORDERING TIME LINE:

We accept orders up to six months in advance, and require at least one month’s notice for all tiered cakes. During peak weddings season, May – October, we ask for two to six month’s notice to ensure your order will fit into our schedule. That being said, we will always do our best to accommodate rush orders.

Untiered cake rounds, sheet cakes, and wedding favors can be added to your order with as little as one week’s notice.

We are able to ship most of our cakes and desserts nationwide via overnight shipping directly to your venue. If your venue is located near one of our kitchens in NYC, LA, DC, or Boston, you can arrange to pick-up your cake directly from one of our kitchens.

CAKE FLAVORS

buttery popcorn cake layered with salty caramel, popcorn crumbs and popcorn pudding + corn fudge on top

buttery popcorn cake layered with salty caramel, popcorn crumbs and popcorn pudding + corn fudge on top

Vanilla rainbow cake, rainbow cake crumbs, sprinkles, vanilla frosting.

Vanilla cake, lemon cheesecake, milk crumbs, pickled tristar strawberry jam, pickled strawberry frosting.

Decadent chocolate cake, chocofied with chocolate chips, then layered with b’day frosting, b’day crumbs and sprinkles.

Decadent chocolate cake, chocofied with chocolate chips, then layered with b’day frosting, b’day crumbs and sprinkles.

Gluten-free vanilla rainbow cake and rainbow cake crumbs, sprinkles, vanilla frosting

Vanilla rainbow cake, rainbow cake crumbs, sprinkles, vanilla frosting.

MORE FROM MILK BAR!

buttery popcorn cake layered with salty caramel, popcorn crumbs and popcorn pudding + corn fudge on top

buttery popcorn cake layered with salty caramel, popcorn crumbs and popcorn pudding + corn fudge on top

Vanilla rainbow cake, rainbow cake crumbs, sprinkles, vanilla frosting.

Toasted oat crust, gooey butter filling.