Skip to product information
1 of 5

Chocolate Milk Bar Pie

Our day 1 classic, ooey, gooey, butter pie has FINALLY gotten a chocolate makeover. We pour a fudgy, rich chocolate filling into a chocolate chip cookie crust and  finish it with a chocolatey powdered sugar topping. We only baked a limited number of pies this holiday, so snag yours now before it's gone!

Bundle and save up to 10% off!

Add up to 2 more items to qualify for a bundle discount
  5% off 10% off
  2-pack 3-pack
1 of 12

Behind the Scenes

    Unboxing Milk Bar

    The Pie with a Cult Following

    DIY A La Mode

Our amazing community

1 of 2
Image of Chocolate Milk Bar Pie
Chocolate Milk Bar Pie $53