Compost Cookie Overhead
Compost Cookie Stack Sliced in Half
Individually Wrapped Compost Cookie
Compost Cookies in 12ct Tin

Compost Cookie® Dozen Tin

The original sweet and salty kitchen sink cookie, with chocolate chips in a deep vanilla base, plus Milk Bar’s five recommended food groups: pretzels, potato chips, graham crackers, coffee, oats, and butterscotch.  

Tin contains 12 individually wrapped cookies.

Get +46 points on this purchase to use towards *free* treats when you join The First Bite Club! Information Icon

Add to Cart - $46.00
Box Icon
We ship nationwide directly to your door.
Schedule your order up to 30 days in advance.
Write a personalized gift note

More Treats

Whether it’s a party of one or a party of ten, we’ve got you with epic desserts.

Assorted Cookie Tin

Birthday Truffles 3-Pack

Chocolate Birthday Truffles 3-Pack

Don't take our word for it

Write a Review


How would you rate the quality of the Milk Bar product?

How would you rate the delivery or in-store pick up experience?

Would you order from Milk Bar online again?

What was the occasion for Milk Bar?

How did you hear about Milk Bar?

How likely are you to recommend Milk Bar to your family or friends?

Thank you for posting a review!

Your review was sent successfully and is now waiting for our staff to publish it.


How to Get Treats Delivered

Box Icon

Our treats are made in a facility that processes:

Peanuts & Tree Nuts


enriched flour (bleached wheat flour, Niacin, Reduced iron, Thiamine mononitrate, Riboflavin, Folic acid), Butter (cream, Natural flavorings), Sugar, Brown sugar, Semisweet chocolate chips (semisweet chocolate, Sugar, Unsweetened chocolate, Cocoa butter, Dextrose, Sunflower lecithin), Butterscotch chips (sugar, Palm kernel and palm oil, Whey powder, Nonfat dry milk solids, Anhydrous dextrose lecithin [an emulsifier], Artificial color [yellow lake #6, Yellow lake #5, Blue lake #2], Salt, And artificial flavor), Eggs, Dextrose, Pretzels (unbleached enriched wheat flour [flour, Niacin, Reduced iron, Thiamine mononitrate-b1, Riboflavin-b2, Folic acid], Malt, Salt oil), Potato chips (potatoes, Vegetable oil [canola oil, Safflower oil, And/or sunflower oil], Salt), Oats, Grahams (unbleached unenriched wheat flour, Graham flour, Sugar, Palm oil, Molasses, Honey, Salt, Sodium bicarbonate), Instant nonfat dry milk, Salt, Coffee, Baking powder (sodium acid pyrophosphate, Sodium bicarbonate, Corn starch, Monocalcium phosphate), Baking soda (leavening), Natural vanilla extract

Enjoy free standard shipping ($18 value) on all orders over $100+ at when shipping to the continental United States. Offer excludes taxes, gift cards, and donations. Offer valid on orders placed online in the United States only from 1/23/23 at 10:00AM EST through 2/9/23 at 11:59PM EST.