wedding cakes & services
Milk Bar wedding cakes are unique! they have unfrosted sides to highlight all of the delicious fillings layered inside. Tier flavors can be mixed and matched from the list of flavors below.
three tier cake (10″,6″,4″): $400* (serves 60)
four tier cake (14″,10″,6″,4″): $575* (serves 140)
additional 10″, 14″, and 18”x26” sheet cakes are available for cutting.
we also offer cookies, cake truffles and slices of crack pie® as takeaways, in addition to alternative desserts like the cake truffle croquembouche!
We require a minimum of 3 weeks notice, and will accept orders up to 6 months in advance. During our busy season (may-october) we ask for 2-3 months notice to ensure we can fit you onto our schedule.
cake tastings are available as either one-on-one tasting appointments in our brooklyn kitchen (monday-friday, 10am-4:30pm), as a tasting package that can be picked up from one of our 5 bakery locations, or we can ship your tasting package anywhere in the usa. the package is $25 and includes a sample of our 12 cake flavors currently available as wedding cake options, we also include a copy of our wedding cakes lookbook. we need at least 48 hours advance notice to prepare your tasting.
planning a wedding outside of NYC? No problem, we can ship your cakes and favors.
*cost does not include delivery fee, and applicable tax. There is an additional $50 summer insulated packing fee for wedding cakes that are delivered outside of NYC May-September.
Looking for more information? Download a free digital copy of our wedding cakes lookbook.
available cake flavors
apple pie cake cheesecake filling, apple compote, pie crumbs
banana cake**banana cream, hazelnut crunch, gianduja fudge
birthday cake rainbow cake crumble, sprinkles, vanilla frosting
carrot cake cheesecake filling, milk crumbs, streusel buttercream
chocolate chip cake passion fruit curd, chocolate crumbs, coffee buttercream
chocolate malt cake malt fudge, malted milk crumbs, charred marshmallow
dulce de leche cake dulce de leche frosting, dulce de leche, milk crumbs
german chocolate jimbo cake* chocolate cake, crack pie filling, flaky coconut, pecan crunch
mint cookies n’ cream cake cookies n’ cream frosting, mint cheesecake, chocolate crumbs
pineapple upside down cake** coconut cake, poached pineapples, yellow cake crumbs and pineapple upside down frosting
pistachio cake** lemon curd, pistachio frosting, milk crumbs
pretzel cake stout ganache, burnt honey frosting, pretzel crumbs
strawberry-lemon cake lemon cheesecake, pickled strawberry jam, milk crumbs