Milk Bar’s Party Cakes have unfrosted sides to highlight all of the delicious fillings layered inside. Party Cakes can be ordered in a variety of flavors and sizes.
6” Cake (feeds 8-12): $38*
10” Cake (feeds 20-30): $90*
14” Cake (feeds 50-60): $150*
18”x26” Sheet Cake (feeds 120-150): $225*
(get all the layers of flavor, texture and wow of our round layer cakes in a new, mondo format!!!)
*cost does not include handling fees, delivery fees and applicable tax.
We typically require 3 days notice to prepare your cake.
Need it sooner? We keep all of our stores stocked with 6” cakes in our three seasonal flavors for same day walk in orders
(see menu for current flavors.) Call 347.577.9504 to reserve a cake for same day pick up from one of our stores.
Delivery and Pick up options:
Shipped to your party: Our 6” and 10” cakes are available to ship nationwide. A selection of flavors and sizes are available for shipping from our online store. Requests for additional flavors and sizes can be made at any time by filling out the form below.
Reserved for in-store pick-up: Our 6” cakes can be reserved for pick up at any of our 5 nyc locations – a selection of flavors can be reserved for pick up at any store through our online reservation system.
Our 10″, 14″ and sheet cakes can be specially requested at anytime by using the form below.
note: due to size constraints 10” and 14” cakes must be picked up from our Williamsburg, Upper West Side, or Carroll Gardens locations. Sheet cakes can be picked up from our Williamsburg location only.
Delivered via 3rd party courier to a NYC location:
Our special orders team can arrange a delivery via courier for any order over $50 going to a location in manhattan or brooklyn. Our courier charges a delivery fee that ranges from $25.90 to $44.90 for deliveries made between the hours of 10am and 6pm, with a minimum of 4 hours notice given. Rush fees apply for deliveries with less than 4 hours notice. An additional after hours fee of $20 applies for deliveries made after 6pm on weekdays, or on saturdays and sundays.
we also offer shipping via UPS within NYC for a more economical option, though we cannot guarantee a delivery time for shipped packages.
available cake flavors
brand new! just for the holidays:
cranberry-gingerbread cake the best holiday flavors come to life as a milk bar cake! layers of spiced gingerbread cake, tart cranberry sauce, pie crumbs all topped with a layer of cream cheese frosting!
apple pie cake cheesecake filling, apple compote, pie crumbs
banana cake**banana cream, hazelnut crunch, gianduja fudge
birthday cake rainbow cake crumble, sprinkles, vanilla frosting
carrot cake cheesecake filling, milk crumbs, streusel buttercream
chocolate chip cake passion fruit curd, chocolate crumbs, coffee buttercream
chocolate malt cake malt fudge, malted milk crumbs, charred marshmallow
dulce de leche cake dulce de leche frosting, dulce de leche, milk crumbs
german chocolate jimbo cake** chocolate cake, crack pie filling, flaky coconut, pecan crunch
mint cookies n’ cream cake cookies n’ cream frosting, mint cheesecake, chocolate crumbs
pineapple upside down cake** coconut cake, pineapple upside down frosting, yellow cake crumbs, cherry-buttermilk soak
pistachio cake** lemon curd, pistachio frosting, milk crumbs
salted pretzel cake stout ganache, burnt honey frosting, salted pretzel crumbs
strawberry-lemon cake lemon cheesecake, pickled strawberry jam, milk crumbs